This post has been updated as of 3/18/2015 to include the PowerPoint Presentation for this program. CLICK HERE FOR THE PROGRAM MATERIALS: LLAM Copyright
This post has been updated as of 3/18/2015 to include the PowerPoint Presentation for this program. CLICK HERE FOR THE PROGRAM MATERIALS: LLAM Copyright
Earlier this week at the Maryland State Archives, Mary Alice Baish the U.S. Superintendent of Documents, presented the National Plant for Access to US Government Information to a group of LLAM members for our February Program. The attached PDF is a copy of her Powerpoint presentation. Check it out for some really helpful nuggets of information!
Next Wednesday, February 18th is LLAM’s opportunity to make a real difference. It is Maryland Library Legislative Day, a chance to meet with your legislators and urge them to support libraries and UEMLA: House Bill 162 and Senate Bill 611. During the day members of the various county libraries visit with their delegations. LLAM has arranged to have county delegations to adopt a LLAMer for a day so you do not need to worry about making appointments, finding buildings, and rooms. They are vets at this process and will welcome your expertise in UELMA.
The agenda for the day is below and the attached PDF includes the day’s agenda, map, and MLA talking points and info on UELMA.
CLICK HERE: Md Lib Leg Day for LLAMers
for more information on the agenda, parking and other important information.
Need more info contact:
Mary Jo Lazun
mjlazun@gmail.com | mjlazun@mdcourts.gov
410-260-1441 work | 410-292-8882 cell
LLAM Needs You In Annapolis On February 18th
Now is the time LLAM really needs you. The Maryland Uniform Legal Materials Act (UELMA) is on track for potential passage for this year. We have a hearing in the House of Delegates scheduled for Wednesday, February 18th at 1:00. That day also coincides with Maryland Library Day. We need you in Annapolis that day.
During Maryland Library Day members of the various county libraries visit with their delegations. Joanie Bellistri and I have asked the Maryland Library Association county delegations to adopt you for a day so you do not need to worry about making appointments, finding buildings, and rooms. They are vets at this process and will welcome your expertise in UELMA.
If you need a crash course in UELMA the AALL and Uniform Commissioner’s web sites have LOTS of information to make you an expert very fast. Joan Bellistri and I are available to answer any questions you may have.
Please let me know if plan to attend, even if right now it is just tentative. I also need to know what county you live in so we can hook you up with your county delegation.
Need more info contact:
Mary Jo Lazun
mjlazun@gmail.com | mjlazun@mdcourts.gov
410-260-1441 work | 410-292-8882 cell
PS if you have not sent the UEMLA message to your delegates PLEASE do so. See https://llamonline.org/2015/02/02/uelma-introduced-in-maryland/
February LLAM Program – with special guest, Mary Alice Baish, Superintendent of Documents, Government Publishing Office (GPO)
Tuesday, Feb. 24, 2015
Maryland State Archives (conference room)
Dr. Edward C. Papenfuse State Archives Building
350 Rowe Boulevard
Annapolis, MD 21401
This event is co-sponsored by LLAM and the Maryland State Archives. The event is a brown bag lunch, with dessert provided by LLAM and the Maryland State Archives.
Directions to the Maryland State Archives are available at http://msa.maryland.gov/msa/intromsa/html/direct.html. There should be parking for all attendees; however, to preserve parking for MSA patrons, please carpool when possible.
We hope to see you there!
Good news! Last week The Maryland Uniform Legal Materials Act (HB 162) was introduced in the General Assembly and is sporting a growing list of sponsors throughout the state. Many thanks to Del. Cathy Vitale of Anne Arundel County who introduced the bill.
We need your help to increase the number of sponsors of the bill so we are asking LLAM members to contact their legislators to request their sponsorship of the bill. If you do not know who represents you (there have been a lot of changes) see Locate Your Legislators.
Below is a sample message that will fit perfectly in the Contact Legislators form available for each legislator. FYI, this form has a 1,500 character limit and the sample message below is around 1400 characters.
Also, please mark your calendar for Maryland Library Legislative Day on February 18. The schedule begins with a terrific breakfast at the Anne Arundel County Circuit Court law library. Details will be forthcoming.
Time is of the essence so please contact your legislators right away and urge them to support UELMA.
For more information, you can contact:
Mary Jo Lazun
410-260-1441
mjlazun@gmail.com
-or-
Joan Bellistri
410-222-1387
joan.bellistri@gmail.com
SAMPLE MESSAGE TO DELEGATES
I write in support of House Bill 162, the Maryland Uniform Electronic Legal Materials Act (UELMA). I strongly urge to you to sponsor this important legislation.
UELMA ensures that online state legal materials that are deemed official — for example, the Code of Maryland, Maryland Rules, reported appellate court decisions, Attorney General Opinions, and the Code of Maryland Regulations — will be preserved in unaltered form and made permanently available to the public.
In Maryland, there have been efforts to discard traditional print access with no method to ensure access, preservation, or authentication to these materials. For example, The Division of State Documents recently proposed offering online-only access to the Maryland Register. Last year the General Assembly exempted the state judiciary from publishing rules committee materials in the Maryland Register if they are promptly posted on the Judiciary web site. Some states no longer publish important legal materials in print — a decision that Maryland may eventually make as well.
UELMA is the people’s insurance policy that our state’s laws are available, preserved, and authenticated online.
To date, twelve states have passed UELMA. By adopting UELMA, Maryland will establish itself as a national leader and demonstrate its commitment to providing its citizens with access to legal materials regardless of format.
Let’s talk about DRM.
Digital Rights Management, or DRM for short, can be generally defined as a system that restricts how one is able to view, save or share digitally acquired information. Much like the now ubiquitous “Terms of Use” agreement required to use most digital services, DRM is a way that publishers can control who, how and where material is being viewed.
DRMs can be particularly problematic for libraries. Librarians are being put in the position of either breaking the electronic locks in order to exercise their legal rights under the Fair use Exemptions or letting a company determine how best to serve library patrons. Fortunately, those put in this predicament now have some recourse. You might recall that in October there was mention of upcoming opportunities for public comment. That day has come! The Copyright Office published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking. <Proposed rule: http://www.copyright.gov/fedreg/2014/79fr73856.pdf >
Here are a few highlights of the proposed rules:
Re-reading the preamble, prior to commenting, is encouraged. The required formatting is very specific and it might be best to use the long or short form guidelines provided by the Copyright office. <Link is here: http://copyright.gov/1201/comment-forms/>
Each of us is in a different and unique position to provide insight, guidance and advocate for our users. Go forth! February 6, 2015, is the deadline for comments.
Part 4 of our Copyright Series is forthcoming.
by Rachel Englander
A vacancy announcement for a Law Librarian (GS-1410-11) has been posted on USAJOBS. The vacancy number is #150003. The application deadline is Friday, February 6, 2015. Additional details are available at: https://www.usajobs.gov/GetJob/ViewDetails/391828900 . Please share the announcement with anyone you feel might be interested in the position. Questions should be addressed to the Library of Congress Employment Office at (202) 707-5627 JobHelp@loc.gov.
The LLAM Executive Board recently passed a resolution in support of the enactment of the Uniform Electronic Legal Material Act in Maryland. UELMA got some traction here in Maryland but ultimately failed to pass.
LLAM has uploaded a copy of the resolution to our website so it’s easy for you to access and review. https://llamonline.org/uelma/llam-resolution-on-uelma/
UELMA is now law in 12 states, with 4 states added in 2014.
Let’s keep the momentum going here in Maryland!
We hope you can join us for LLAM’s 2014 holiday party!
CLICK HERE to register and pay online now!
Location Information:
University of Baltimore School of Law, Top Floor
1401 N. Charles Street, Baltimore, MD 21201
When: December 15, 2014, 5:30 P.M. – 8:00 P.M.
Tickets – $25.00
View directions at: http://www.ubalt.edu/about-ub/directions/ .
For more information, see below, or return to LLAMonline.org .
Email James Durham at james.durham@mdcourts.gov if you have any questions!

Holiday Party Menu:
The ven-diagram of copyright and licensing rights: little overlap
This is part two of our multi-part series on copyright.
One of my current, favorite soapbox topics is e-books. In fact, I was tempted to title this post E-books: The great evil of our time but thought that might too easily reveal my feelings on the matter.
E-books have been the subject of quite a lot of controversy in the library community. The conversation has centered on their difficulty to access, lend and administer. Bess Reynolds of Debovise & Pilmpton LLP recently authored a white paper (published by ALTA & AALL) that lists, in perfect detail, the overly complicated systems employed by the top vendors and the administrative nightmares that result. (There was a follow up published in Spectrum in April, 2014.) Bess’s paper(s) succinctly sums up many of the technical issues regarding e-books, but it was one of the closing lines that really stuck with me.
“[W]e should demand the right to own e-books just as we own our print titles.”
Think about that for a moment. As fellow librarians, I’m confident that most of you agree. While frustrating and often obnoxious, the clunky technical hoops of the vendors’ e-book platforms are the least of our worries when it comes to copyright. Copyright Rules dictate the terms by which Libraries license e-books and are written to work around the First Sale Doctrine and almost all of the other regulations libraries are accustomed accommodating for print works. This core issue of “exclusive rights” affects user borrowing privileges, inter-library loans, accessibility and historic preservation; basically everything that makes libraries, libraries.
As is the norm in electronic resources, libraries rarely own e-books outright. Once the contract is over, so too is access to the content. In many cases it is the vendors who get to determine how the information is accessed, stored, viewed and/or transmitted. The main question here is how do we as librarians increase our rights to use the information as libraries are wont to do (as in the examples given above). Contract negotiations might be an alternative for extending our options of how to use it, but that assumes that we have some leverage. Because the legal publishing world is concentrated in 3-5 key players, law libraries do not always have the option of picking someone else to work with or taking a stand against overly aggressive licensing agreements. Smaller private libraries, in particular, do not always have a good alternative to use as leverage.
If this state of affairs concerns you, here are a few concrete suggestions of what you can do to help make advancements in this area.
Part 3 of our Copyright Series is forthcoming!
The Fall Newsletter is now here! We hope you are enjoying the beautiful weather and changing colors!
On Tuesday, October 28, after LLAM’s fall board meeting, the Thurgood Marshall Law Library hosted a brown bag lunch and program featuring two presentations by Gail Warren, Director of the Virginia State Law Library and Treasurer of the American Association of Law Libraries. In the first, Ms. Warren looked back at the predictions made by AALL’s Special Committee on Law Libraries in the Digital Age in its 2002 report Beyond the Boundaries: Report of the Special Committee on the Future of Law Libraries in the Digital Age. This report provided impetus for the formation of Legal Information Preservation Alliance in 2003, and the Chesapeake Digital Preservation Group in 2007. Predicting the future of law libraries is more art than science, and her frank assessment will be useful for those members who are called upon to make long term planning decisions in their own shops: Beyond the Boundaries, LIPA and Chesapeake (slides).
In the second presentation, Ms. Warren was joined by Mary Jo Lazun, Head of Collection Management at the Maryland State Law Library, and Joan Bellistri, Director of the Anne Arundel County Public Law Library, for an update on the work of the Chesapeake Digital Preservation Group. The Chesapeake Digital Preservation Group is a collaborative effort of Legal Information Preservation Alliance members to address the challenges of born-digital legal information shared by the Virginia and Maryland State Law Libraries, Georgetown University Law Library, and Harvard University Law Library: The Chesapeake Digital Preservation Group (slides).
LLAM is collaborating with LLSDC to bring you this event! Please see below for RSVP information.
LSDC Access to Justice Committee is pleased to hold its first event!
When: December 9, 2014
Where: Public Defender Service for DC
633 Indiana Ave NW, 2nd floor
Time: 12 noon to 1:30 pm
Please join the Access to Justice Committee as we welcome our speaker, Emily Feltren, AALL’s Director of Government Relations, to our first event. Emily will be discussing what is happening with A2J initiatives at the National Level and other Law Library Chapters around the country.
Lunch will be provided.
Hope you can join us!
RSVP to Laura Moorer, Esq
lmoorer@pdsdc.org
Legal Reference Specialist
Public Defender Service for DC
633 Indiana Ave NW
Washington DC 20004
202-824-2409
f 202-824-2174
LLAM’s Vice President and Chair of the Programs Committee, James Durham, has put together an exciting list of events for the next 6 months. Please check out the list below and mark your calendar so you don’t miss out on any of the fun!
If you have any questions or would like more information, please forward your inquiries to LLAMNewsMD.
We hope you can join us for the LLAM Holiday Party & Silent Auction at the University of Baltimore on December 15, 2014. More information on registration will be coming soon, but email us at llamnewsmd@gmail.com if you have any questions!
The following is the first offering of a multi part series on Copyright that will be published over the next month.
Copyright.
In library circles it’s a dirty word.
When I use the word “copyright” in my professional capacity, it is usually when I am trying to convince someone to desist from something, preferably immediately. As a librarian, it is my least favorite conversation. I’m sure you hate having it as well. And copyright probably comes up far more often than you would like. I don’t know about you, but the reason I hate the conversation is because there is so much debate about what copyright law is exactly and how it works.
Copyright law can be loosely defined as the combination of laws governing the rights of the producers or owners regarding the use, sale and availability of works. As professionals, we work with copyright material every day. We also rely on a number of exceptions written into copyright law that apply specifically to libraries in order to serve our patron’s needs. Copyright is not just the law that protects the owners rights. It is also a framework that allows for fair use or license agreements with people who want to use what they created (Us!).
Deceptively straightforward looking, isn’t it?
Sorry to burst your bubble. Those of you who breathed a sigh of relief upon reading the last paragraph will be distressed to learn that the copyright landscape is changing in a number of significant ways. By “changes”, of course, I mean lawsuits.
There are two recent cases in particular which we as a profession should be looking at very closely. The first is Authors Guild,Inc. v. HathiTrust. The second, the Google Books case, is currently before the Supreme Court. Both have significant implications regarding the role of technology, accessibility and the transformational nature of fully searchable titles. There have also been rumblings of changes coming from the Legislative branch of the Government. The times, they are a’changing (was that a copyright violation? Read on!)
The Honorable Maria A. Pallante (who is the U.S. Register of Copyrights) gave a well-received lecture at Columbia Law last year. Her remarks set off a firestorm of discussion. Her basic position is that the law governing copyright needs an overhaul. Changes in technology have always driven changes in copyright law. Usually, law has lagged behind somewhat. In the past, when technology did not change quite so quickly, that lag was a drag race between a souped-up hot rod and a VW bug. In the last few decades however, the lag is more like a bicycle trying to keep pace with a space shuttle.
Not surprisingly, Congress has been holding hearings on this subject in the last year. Sources in the know have hinted that a series of bill will be introduced in the near future. These bills will amend copyright law for the first time since 1976 (legislation passed in 1976 but effective date was January, 1978). As a point of reference, 1976 was the year that Steve Wozniak designed a single board computer for hobbyists called the “Apple 1”. Everyone take a moment now to glance at your i-phone and marvel at the fact that we are working off legislation that was created when the fanciest technology available looked like something from The Flintstones.
Photo Credit: Ed Uthman / Flickr
I am an unabashed policy nerd, so I am looking forward to the upcoming opportunities for public comment. While this definition of excitement may call into question my quality of life, I think that, in this instance, the entire profession really ought to be excited about this opportunity. Because 2016 will be an election year (and we all know how much legislation gets passed in an election year), this next cycle may be the next window for quite some time in which THE LAW MIGHT ACTUALLY CHANGE. Look at your i-phone again. Think of that vintage 1976 Rube Goldberg device you just saw. Judging by the historical record of copyright revision, this is possibly the only time in our professional careers that copyright law will be rewritten. Think of what you do daily at work. You make decisions about purchasing information and granting access to information. You help people find and use information. You are the information guide and sherpa. Your voice, the voice of the library professionals, is the most knowledgeable voice in the arena of the use of copyrighted information. Shouldn’t it logically be the loudest voice in the debate over what the laws that govern copyright say?
Yes, it should be. It should be (I say loudly with exclamation points)! We, the librarians, the information lighthouses that lead the meandering ships of knowledge seekers towards safe shores, we should be the ones advocating for changes in antiquated laws!
We should advocate the heck out of it! And other, stronger, words! Think of every time you’ve been confounded by usage, every time you’ve had to warn someone (using very sharp words) to read but not copy under pain of death by copyright infringement lawsuit. We have a duty to our library patrons, our profession, and (dare I say it) to our own sanity to advocate for laws that actually reflect the technology that we are using.
Don’t touch that dial (as they used to say in the days when our current copyright laws were written). I will be keeping all of you informed of opportunities for public comment as the process of revision goes forward in Congress. Stay tuned to this station (or blog in the current technological parlance) for part 2 of our series on Copyright!
-Rachel Englander
Maryland State Department of Education, Division of Library Development and Services will be hosting a workshop and panel discussion called “Alternative Revenue Streams: Development, Fundraising, and Grant Writing for Libraries.” The event will include a panel discussion by development and fundraising specialists from across the state, an introduction to and presentation on Finding Funders by Maryland’s Foundation Center Funding Information Network Supervisors, a lightning round discussion of fundraising events that have succeeded and failed, and a grant writing workshop focused on developing a specific idea or project into a grant proposal that can be used to win grants and entice funders.
The program will take place at Miller Library on September 9 from 9am to 4pm. The day’s agenda is attached. You can register here.
Please contact Rocco DeBonis with any questions at rdebonis@msde.state.md.us
Rocco DeBonis
LSTA Grant Coordinator
Maryland State Department of Education, Division of Library Development and Services
200 West Baltimore Street, Baltimore MD 21201
410.767.0437 phone | 410.333.2507 fax | rocco.debonis@maryland.gov
Head of Content Acquisitions and Management
Georgetown University Law Library
The Head of Content Acquisitions and Management is responsible for the supervision and management of all aspects of acquisitions and serials operations, which includes ordering and receipt of library materials in all formats, implementing collection management policies, and overseeing vendor relations and purchasing/licensing agreements. This position directly supervises seven staff in the library’s Acquisitions and Collection Care department.
The Head of Content Acquisitions and Management also plays a key role in the assessment and management of the library’s collection. This includes coordinating the selection and de-selection of library materials; compiling and reporting statistical data for collection assessment; coordinating and pursuing intercampus and interlibrary collaborative collection development opportunities; and working cooperatively with subject selectors, staff across all departments in the library, and faculty to provide access to information.
Required
Master’s degree from an ALA-accredited school of library and/or information studies, or equivalent; strong supervisory skills; excellent written and verbal communication skills; at least two years of collection development experience; familiarity with integrated library systems.
Preferred
Law library experience or familiarity with legal publishing trade and vendors; Acquisitions experience; JD or equivalent.
Salary is commensurate with experience and qualifications.
To apply for this position, please submit applications via the Georgetown University Jobs website by using Job Number 20141165. Address applications to Stacy Queen, and include a cover letter, a current resume, and the names and contact information for three references.
Review of applications will begin on August 6, 2014 and continue until the position is filled.
Georgetown University is an EOE/AA employer.
Join the LLAM Dine-Around in San Antonio
Saturday, July 12th at 6:30 pm
If you are you attending the 2014 AALL Annual Meeting & Conference in San Antonio, please consider joining the members of LLAM for the annual “LLAM Dine-Around.” This year, the group will meet at La Paloma Riverwalk, 215 Lasoya, on the San Antonio Riverwalk, which is a short distance from the Henry B. Gonzalez Convention Center. The reservation, under the name of “Maryland Law Librarians,” is for 6:30 p.m. on Saturday evening, July 12. We have requested a patio or Riverwalk table, if available. To view photos and a menu, visit http://www.lapalomariverwalk.com. Vegetarian options are offered. If you plan to attend, please RSVP to james.durham@mdcourts.gov, so that the reservation can be amended to accommodate the actual size of our group. See you in Texas!
By: James G. Durham, Deputy Director of the Maryland State Law Library
SAVE THE DATE for this upcoming symposium about link rot that will be held at Georgetown University Law Library!
The Web is fluid and mutable, and this is a “feature” rather than a “bug”. But it also creates challenges in the legal environment (and elsewhere) when fixed content is necessary for legal writers to support their conclusions. Judges, attorneys, academics, and others using citations need systems and practices to preserve web content as it exists in a particular moment in time, and make it reliably available.
On October 24, 2014 Georgetown University Law Library in Washington, D.C. will host a symposium that explores the problem of link and reference rot.
Preliminary Agenda
• Keynote speech to contextualize the issues and discuss conflict between the naturally fluid state of the internet and the expectations by legal professionals that once something is published (in whatever form) that it should be static.
• Presentations and panel on “Whose problem is this?” with members from academia, government, the judiciary, law reviews
• The webmaster’s view – what pressures are there to continually change websites to reflect current look/feel trends, new usability technologies, etc. that contribute to link rot?
• Presentations and panel on current initiatives with members from organizations like The Chesapeake Project, Perma.cc, Archive.org, etc. What tools exist, and what are the remaining needs?
• Wrap-up detailing current, pragmatic steps attendees can take upon going home.
Presenters include
• Jonathan Zittrain, Harvard University
• Robert Miller, Internet Archive
• Prof. Karen Eltis, University of Toronto Law School
• Rod Wittenberg, Reed Technology and Information Services
• Kim Dulin, Harvard University
• Carolyn Campbell, Georgetown University Law Library
We will post additional information as it gets finalized to the event webpage at: http://www.law.georgetown.edu/library/404/
Date: Friday, May 16th 2014
Time: 4-6pm
Place: Gertrude’s, Baltimore Museum of Art, 10 Art Museum Drive, Baltimore, MD 21218
Cost: $25 per person. PayPal payment is preferred. You may also send a check addressed to “LLAM” to Bijal Shah at 1401 N. Charles St., Baltimore, MD 21201.
Parking: Free along North Charles Street. View driving directions HERE.
Celebrate the season with fellow LLAM members at Gertrude’s restaurant at the Baltimore Museum of Art. Take a self-directed tour of the museum and Cone Collection before enjoying an open bar and scrumptious hors d’oeuvres in the Sculpture Garden Pavilion.
This event supports Operation Paperback. Please donate money and/or books to help send books to American troops, veterans, and their families.
LLAM’s All Access to Justice Legal Research Institute was held last Friday, March 21st at the University of Baltimore Angelos Law Center. The event was a huge success; Kate Martin and her committee did a terrific job and we thank them for their efforts!
Librarians from across the state and all over the country convened at UB to learn about current issues and solutions for ensuring Access to Justice for all of our patrons. The programming covered the A2J topic from a variety of aspects; discussions included the basics of what Access to Justice is, how Public Libraries play a role in the future of the movement, what Private Law Librarians can do to advance the cause, the Academic Library’s role, and the type of assistance State and County Law Libraries should provide. The major theme throughout the day was that we need to remember we are librarians and while we can help a patron locate and utilize the correct resources, we must be careful not to give legal advice.
The number of Self-Represented Litigants (“SRLs”) in the country is growing for a variety of reasons and the Librarian’s role in helping them navigate the confusing and tumultuous legal landscape is an essential one. It was exhilarating to gather with librarians from a variety of backgrounds and learn how each of us can contribute to this effort.
You can find more information, videos, slides, and PDFs of all of the handouts from the seminar HERE.
-Sara Thomas
Communications Committee Chair
We want to make next time even better! If you haven’t done so already, please take a moment to give us some feedback about your conference experience at https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/justice2014.